I feel confused .... each time that I read a story to K~ which perennially potrays Stepmothers as witchy and bitchy and the fairest skin attracting the richest and handsome Prince. I keep thinking about the long term ill effects of these stories and feel a strong urge to graduate K~ to the more sensible desi story books like Jataka Tales, Panchatantra, Adventures of Meena and many more. Alas! These simple and humble books do not take to K~'s fancy as much as their english counterparts which are better packaged with bright colours and glossy pages with attractive pictures and more often encouraged and promoted by her school teacher.
Be it the Stepmother of Snow White or Cinderella or the Hansel and Gretel duo or Beauty ...... she is never at peace with herself and inflicts atrocities on her step kids who are the central characters. In real life, my experience has been contrary where I have met two stepmoms who have proved their ability to love and accept previous kids of their husband with such natural and effortless passion and affection that if undisclosed no mortal could have ever realised the stepness. For the sake of providing an identity let me name them as Mrs. Ghosh and Mrs. Chitaley .... such lovely women. Mrs. Ghosh, a homoeopath practitioner was married in her late thirties to the then widower, Mr.Ghosh with an adorable four year old daughter Lota. She embraced Lota with an effortless ease befriending her at first and then slowly enticing her through her interesting games and culinary skills. I could hear their happy chuckles and rare disagreements from the backyard of my house every morning pleasantly surprised each time as my notions set in childhood regarding stepmoms got smashed. We were not really family friends, therefore losing contact after we shifted our residence elsewhere but every year during Durga Pujo I spotted them in Kali Bari just like any other mom-daughter duo. She would hang around with her mom more than she did with her dad. Mrs. Chitaley had a similar story too. The only difference being that she was a divorcee with a daughter of her own before she remarried Mr. Chitaley, a widower with a two year son. What a complete and happy family they make! Touchwood! She thrashes the naughty son just like her own, a complete brat that he is and spends sleepless afternoons painfully making him do his homework and teaching. And yet, the son comes running to hug his (step)Mom each time she steps out to make her (step)Son empty the glass of milk that he left behind on the dining table.
GOD could not be present everywhere ... so he made MOTHER to let each being experience HIS unconditional and boundless love through her. Each woman has been endowed with immense motherly capabilities which takes precedence over many other important personal desires like her career, her interests, her body so much so that it overpowers all her relationships and she lands up being a mother to her husband, her parents and in-laws taking care of them and feeling responsible towards their needs. Pity that we equate (step)mothers with such hostility and treachery in the young and unassuming minds right in their formitive years.
The other fact that keeps poking my mind is the glorification of the white, beautiful skin. K~ is dusky, just like me, but her sharp features and twinkling eyes make her attractive. When I read such elaborate beauty descriptions where "Snow White has skin as white as snow and lips as red as blood, Cinderella was the fairest amongst all and the Prince would not dance with any other lady" .... K~ would start wondering if she is fine in her looks. She would want to become like them and would want to be married to some handsome and rich prince in future .... What the Hell! How do I convince her that it is the inner beauty which makes any girl more adorable than her skin. And that appearing attractive is not an ambitious goal ... is it? There are better objectives in life .... career, shaping lives of family members etc. She would stare at herself at the mirror and ask "Mirror, Mirror on the wall, Who is fairest of them all?" adjusting her hair and moderating her facial expressions to look beautiful. She wants to apply Fair and Lovely, a skin whitening cream, unfortunately encouraged by some of the family members too. It is sad that stories read to children in the best of intentions can lead to such dangerous obsessions. Why should girls be potrayed as items to be displayed to kings and princes. Why are girls never shown as the ruling and strong characters? Why does Mumma Bear cook, wash and clean when Papa Bear reads and Baby Bear plays in the garden? Why does stepmother make Snow White eat a poisoned apple and Cinderella gets harassed?
There is a prevailing sense of helplessness in me as a parent because these age old stories which are highly promoted actually harms the mindset of our children ..... Each time that K~ effortlessly narrates these stories and appreciates the applause that follows, such notions and bias actually deepen further into her innocent mind.